Skip to content
From £600 ·Book a video call →

How to Choose WordPress Plugins (And Avoid Bad Ones)

By Tom · Last reviewed · 5 minute read

Only install a plugin you need, and check first that it is recently updated, widely used, compatible with your WordPress version and has an active support forum. Test your site speed before and after, delete anything you don't use, and never use pirated plugins.

On this page

Good WordPress plugins make your site better. Bad ones leave you with a slow, insecure site.

I see this all the time. Business owners install dozens of plugins without thinking. Then they wonder why their site loads like treacle and gets hacked twice a year.

This guide covers how to pick plugins that help your business rather than harm it.

What You'll Learn

By the end of this guide, you'll know how to:

  • Evaluate plugin quality and security
  • Avoid plugins that slow down your site
  • Keep your plugin collection lean and effective
  • Spot the warning signs of a bad plugin

Rules for Choosing Plugins

1. Less is More

Every plugin adds code to your site. More code means more things that can break, more security risks, and slower loading times.

Ask yourself whether you need it, not whether it would be nice to have.

If you can't say exactly why you need a plugin, you probably don't.

2. Check the Plugin's Health First

Before installing any plugin, check these things in the WordPress plugin directory:

Active Installations: Plugins with 100,000+ active installs are usually safer bets. They've been tested by thousands of users.

Last Updated: If it hasn't been updated in over 6 months, walk away. WordPress changes frequently. Outdated plugins become security holes.

WordPress Version Compatibility: Must work with your WordPress version. If it says "tested up to" a version from two years ago, skip it.

Support Forum Activity: Check whether the developers respond to user problems. Radio silence is a red flag.

Step-by-Step Plugin Evaluation Process

Step 1: Research Before You Install

Never install a plugin on impulse. Research first.

  1. Read the plugin description carefully. What exactly does it do? How does it do it?

  2. Check reviews, but be smart about it. Look for detailed reviews, not just star ratings. What specific problems do users mention?

  3. Visit the developer's website. Professional developers have proper websites with documentation and support info.

Step 2: Security Checks

Security should be your top priority. Here's what to look for:

  1. Developer reputation: Recognise the name? Companies like Yoast, WooCommerce, and Automattic have solid track records.

  2. Code quality indicators:

    • Professional plugin pages with proper screenshots
    • Detailed documentation
    • Clear privacy policy
    • Regular security updates
  3. Vulnerability history: Search "[plugin name] vulnerability" on Google. If you find multiple recent security issues, consider alternatives.

Step 3: Performance Impact Assessment

Some plugins are resource hogs. They'll slow your site to a crawl.

Before installing:

After installing:

  • Test again and compare
  • If your site slowed down significantly, remove the plugin

Red flags for performance:

  • Plugins that load lots of external files
  • Social media widgets that load content from multiple platforms
  • Backup plugins that run during peak hours
  • Page builders (unless you need them)

Must-Have vs Nice-to-Have Plugins

Must-Have Plugins (Most Sites Need These)

Security: A plugin like Wordfence or Sucuri for basic protection.

SEO: Yoast SEO or Rank Math to help with search rankings. My WordPress websites come with SEO plugins configured properly.

Backup: UpdraftPlus or similar for automatic backups.

Performance: A caching plugin like WP Rocket or W3 Total Cache.

Nice-to-Have Plugins

Contact Forms: WordPress doesn't include one, so you'll need a plugin if you want a form. Pick one well-known option and stick with it.

Analytics: Google Analytics can be added without a plugin.

Social Sharing: Check whether people use these buttons before you keep them.

Common Plugin Mistakes to Avoid

Installing Too Many Plugins

I've seen WordPress sites with more than 50 plugins. That's far too many.

Most business websites need 8-12 plugins maximum. If you have more than 20, you're probably doing something wrong.

Keeping Inactive Plugins

Deactivated plugins still pose security risks. If you're not using it, delete it completely.

Ignoring Updates

Plugin updates often contain security fixes. Enable automatic updates for trusted plugins, or check weekly manually.

Using Nulled (Pirated) Plugins

Never use pirated premium plugins. They often contain malware and won't receive security updates.

How to Audit Your Current Plugins

Step 1: List All Active Plugins

Go to Plugins > Installed Plugins in your WordPress admin. Write down every active plugin.

Step 2: Ask Three Questions

For each plugin, ask:

  1. When did I last use this feature?
  2. Could I achieve this without a plugin?
  3. Is this plugin still maintained?

Step 3: Remove the Deadweight

Deactivate and delete plugins that fail these tests.

Troubleshooting Plugin Problems

Site Crashed After Installing a Plugin?

  1. Access your site via FTP or hosting control panel
  2. Navigate to /wp-content/plugins/
  3. Rename the problem plugin's folder (add -disabled to the name)
  4. Your site should work again

Plugin Conflicts

If something breaks after installing a plugin:

  1. Deactivate all plugins
  2. Activate them one by one
  3. Test your site after each activation
  4. When the problem returns, you've found the culprit

Performance Issues

Use a plugin like Query Monitor to identify slow plugins. It shows exactly which plugins are slowing down each page.

Plugin Security Best Practices

Regular Maintenance

Include plugin updates in your website maintenance checklist. I handle this for sites on my care plans.

Monitor Security Bulletins

Subscribe to WordPress security newsletters. When vulnerabilities are announced, update immediately.

Use Staging Sites

Test new plugins on a staging site first. Never install plugins directly on your live site.

Keep WordPress Updated

Plugin security depends on WordPress core being secure too. Keep everything updated.

Finding Quality Plugins

WordPress.org Plugin Directory: The safest source. All plugins are reviewed before publication.

Premium Plugin Companies: Companies like Gravity Forms, Advanced Custom Fields Pro, and WP Rocket have excellent reputations.

Developer Recommendations: Follow respected WordPress developers on Twitter. They often recommend quality plugins.

Sources to Avoid

Free premium plugin sites: These often distribute malware.

Random websites offering "WordPress plugins": Stick to official sources.

Very cheap marketplaces: If it seems too good to be true, it probably is.

Further Reading

Plugins are only one part of WordPress security.

Learn about WordPress as a content management system to understand how plugins fit into the bigger picture.

Consider my care plans if you'd rather have someone else handle plugin updates and security monitoring.

Free toolPHP security checkSee which PHP version your site shows and whether it has the latest security fixes.Try it
Want a second opinion?Tell me what you need and I'll give you honest advice, even if it's not me.
Get in touch