Skip to content
From £600 ·Book a video call →

How to Check if Your Website is Working for Your Business

By Tom · Last reviewed · 5 minute read

A website is working if it brings in enquiries or sales, not just visitors. Track conversions in Google Analytics, check Search Console for the searches that find you, keep pages loading in under three seconds, and regularly test your own site on a phone and fill in your own contact form.

On this page

Your website might look great. The question is whether it's making you money.

Too many business owners treat their website like a business card. It exists, it looks professional, job done. That's not enough anymore.

It should bring in leads, bookings or sales and build trust with potential customers. If it isn't doing that, you're wasting money.

Why Most Business Websites Underperform

Most business websites underperform because owners don't know what to measure. You can't fix what you don't track.

Here's what I see when Cardiff businesses come to me for help:

  • Beautiful sites with zero enquiries
  • High visitor numbers but no conversions
  • Owners who don't know where their traffic comes from
  • Websites that look good but don't sell

The Metrics That Matter

Forget vanity metrics like page views. These numbers tell you if your website is working for your business.

1. Conversion Rate

This is the most important one: the share of visitors who take action.

A "conversion" depends on your business:

  • Contact form submissions
  • Phone calls
  • Appointment bookings
  • Online purchases
  • Newsletter signups

How to check: Set up key events (what used to be called goals or conversions) in Google Analytics. Without it, you can't tell what's working.

What's good: 2-5% for most industries. Service businesses often see higher rates.

2. Lead Quality

One good customer is worth more than 100 poor enquiries.

Track where your best customers come from. Which pages do they visit? Which content do they read? This tells you what's working.

3. Page Speed

Slow sites lose business, and both Google and your customers notice.

How to check: Use my free website audit tool for an instant speed report.

What's acceptable: Under 3 seconds. Under 2 seconds is better. Under 1 second is excellent.

DIY Website Health Check

You don't need expensive tools or technical knowledge. Here's what any business owner can do:

The 5-Minute Test

  1. Google your business name. Do you appear? Good start.
  2. Search for your main service + your location (e.g. "accountant Cardiff"). Where do you rank?
  3. Try your website on your phone. Does everything work?
  4. Time how long your homepage takes to load. Count in your head: one-thousand-one, one-thousand-two...
  5. Complete your own contact form. Do you get the enquiry?

The Customer Test

Pretend you're a potential customer. Start from Google. Try to:

  • Find your phone number
  • Understand what you do
  • Get a quote or make contact
  • Find your address

If any step is difficult, you're losing business.

The Competition Check

Visit your main competitors' websites. Be honest:

  • Are they easier to use?
  • Do they load faster?
  • Is their message clearer?
  • Do they appear higher in Google?

Use it to see what customers have come to expect.

Tools Every Business Owner Should Use

Google Analytics (Free)

Shows who visits your site and what they do. You need it to track website ROI.

Set up key events for enquiries, phone calls, and other important actions. Without this data, you're guessing.

Google Search Console (Free)

Tells you which searches bring people to your site. Reveals technical problems Google finds.

If you only use one tool, make it this one.

Website Trust Score Tools

Trust signals matter. Use my website trust score checker to see how trustworthy your site appears to visitors.

Red Flags Your Website Isn't Working

Watch for these warning signs:

Traffic Red Flags:

  • Visitor numbers dropping month on month
  • Most traffic comes from social media (not search)
  • High bounce rate (people leave immediately)
  • No returning visitors

Business Red Flags:

  • Fewer enquiries than last year
  • Customers say they found you elsewhere
  • You rely entirely on word-of-mouth
  • Your phone never rings from website visitors

Technical Red Flags:

  • Site takes longer than 5 seconds to load
  • Doesn't work properly on phones
  • Contact forms don't work
  • Google can't find your site

The Professional vs DIY Decision

You can check these basics yourself. But improving website performance often needs professional help.

DIY if:

  • Your site gets decent traffic
  • You understand your analytics
  • Technical issues are minor
  • You have time to learn

Call professionals if:

  • Traffic is declining
  • You don't understand the data
  • Technical problems are complex
  • Your time is better spent on your business

My care plans include monitoring, so I can spot problems before they hurt your business.

Quick Action Checklist

Start with these immediate improvements:

□ Install Google Analytics and Search Console □ Set up conversion tracking for enquiries □ Test your website on mobile □ Check your site speed □ Review last month's enquiry sources □ Compare your site to main competitors □ Update any outdated content □ Fix obvious technical issues □ Add clear calls-to-action on key pages □ Make contact details easy to find

Local Cardiff Business Advantage

Cardiff businesses can do well in local search with the right approach.

Focus on local SEO for Welsh businesses. Cardiff customers search differently than London customers. They use local terms, mention specific areas, and value local businesses.

Make sure your website mentions Cardiff, your specific area, and the communities you serve. This helps both Google and customers find you.

What Good Performance Looks Like

Every business is different, but healthy websites share common traits:

  • Steady traffic growth month on month
  • Regular enquiries from the website
  • Good Google rankings for important searches
  • Fast loading times
  • Mobile-friendly design
  • Clear conversion paths
  • Regular content updates

If your website ticks these boxes, it's working for your business.

When to Invest in Improvements

Website performance isn't set-and-forget, because markets, competitors and technology all change.

Review your website performance quarterly. Ask:

  • Are enquiries increasing?
  • Is traffic growing?
  • Are conversion rates improving?
  • Do customers compliment your website?

If the answers are mostly no, it's time to invest in improvements.

FAQ

Q: How long should I wait to see results from website changes? A: SEO changes take 3-6 months. Technical improvements show results immediately. Content marketing builds momentum over 6-12 months.

Q: My website gets visitors but no enquiries. What's wrong? A: Usually a conversion problem. Check your contact forms work, your phone number is visible, and your calls-to-action are clear.

Q: Should I rebuild my website or improve what I have? A: Improve first unless your site is very old or completely broken. Small changes often deliver big improvements.

Q: How much should I spend on website improvements? A: Start with free improvements and basic tools. For most Cardiff businesses, £500-2000 per year on website improvements delivers good ROI.

If your website isn't bringing in business, start with these checks and make the obvious improvements. If you want help, get in touch.

Free toolWebsite trust scoreHow trustworthy your site looks to a new visitor, plus the technical basics.Try it
Want a second opinion?Tell me what you need and I'll give you honest advice, even if it's not me.
Get in touch